Liars All (2013) is more of a mystery thriller than a horror film, but I felt compelled to write about it because not that long ago, seriously like a month ago, I was tinkering with an idea for a slasher movie revolving around a game of Truth or Dare. Well, damn it, this movie kind of sort of beat me to it. Just goes to show that no idea is original. My version would of course have more blood and gore, but the premise is still almost the same. Damn it. Nevertheless, I watched this last night before I went to bed, I dreamed about it, and now of course it is embedded in my subconscious. Don’t get me wrong, this movie is not that good, but I found it to be entertaining. Without further adieu about my ramblings, here is what the movie is about…
A group of friends gather for a party on New Year’s Eve in London. When Dennis (Torrance Coombs, HBO’s The Tudors) brings back the group to his place, Missy (Gillian Zinser, The CW’s 90210) is already there waiting to crash the party. Doesn’t matter. She has made a NC-17 version of Truth or Dare (you know, the kind you always wanted to play, but realized there’s only ever that one hot person at the party that inevitably is always unavailable therefore refuses [smartly] to not participate. It is just the way it is). Party ensues, party game commences, then out on a dare Missy is shot dead. Only two other people on the scene with Missy, four suspects. Was it murder or was it suicide?
OK so a little back story. Missy is an American student studying in London. She meets and falls in love with Dennis, a professional footballer (we can say it, soccer player!). He dumps her and soon after gets engaged to a famous pop singer. This news makes Missy totally unhinged and the Truth or Dare game was made to get Dennis back into her arms.
Enter Mike (Matt Lanter, The CW’s 90210) and Katie (Sara Paxton, Shark Night 3D), Missy’s friends from America that came to visit. Mike is unconditionally in love with Missy, Katie is in love with Mike and knows Missy is bad for him. Missy knows of Mike’s affections and likes to tempt and tease him, driving him crazy. The deeper the hooks get into Mike, the more angry Katie becomes. So we have a love-square of dangerous proportions going on here. Dennis loves his fiance, Missy loves Dennis, Mike loves Missy, Katie loves Mike. To add to that at one point during the party Dennis tries to hook up with Katie. Yeah, not a very faithful guy and all in all a very messy situation.
Going back to the dare. Dennis, Missy, and Mike have to break into a home and steal something valuable. Once inside Missy throws Dennis’s jersey into a corner as “evidence” and depending what version of the story you hear, Dennis’s, Mike’s, or what the investigator thinks happened, a gun is pulled out as part of the prank. Missy loads it, then from there it’s all speculation of what really happened. Did she pull the trigger? Was there a scuffle between her and one (or both) of the guys? Did one (or both) of the guys shoot her? I will leave that mystery to you my gently crazed reader to find out.
The movie is a jumbled mess of back story (how Missy became crazed) and then the three different versions of what happened at the shooting, plus Katie’s version of what happened at the party. Katie delivers us a very thoughtful speech about how sometimes you will take the pain for the pleasure in regards to why she started making out with Dennis, but ended it before it got further. That speech was probably the best part of the dialogue throughout the movie. I forgot to mention that Mike has a video camera that he uses to record the entire night, but said he stopped recording when they broke into the apartment. Was he telling the truth?
There you have it. A movie for those bored, lonely nights when you wish you could get a group of friends together for some drunken debauchery. Yeah, good luck with that.